Brodie is on Nutro and does very well on it. However watching a vet the news scared me. I called my vet and she told me to take him off it STAT if I felt there was a problem. It is only the dry food which is consodered to have 12 percent moisture (wet). However this vet said 66 percent kidney funnction could be gone before a problem shows up. I do not want to hurt him with a immediate switch I also do not want to harm him for continuing to give it. The news broadcaster said sadly the dogs lost are conidered property not family. I beg to differ I have had the little guy for 9 yrs and his is family. I d not buy the stove toys or hug the stove. THE STOVE IS PROPERTY BRODIE IS FAMILY.