Just Labradors banner

1 - 7 of 7 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
11,362 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Anyone feed their dogs this? We did some shopping around last night and decided to switch the dogs over to something other than Solid Gold Wolf King. We like the Solid Gold but

1) Remy needs to eat waaaay to much of it to keep weight on
2) Brooklyn is having the grass and stick obsession which makes me wonder if she is missing something nutritionally and
3) Our local pet store is actually phasing it out since not a lot of people are buying it.

We were looking at the Evo, the Innova and the Natural Balance and we decided to go with the Prairie. They seem to have a lot of differnent flavors and I like their rotational plan. We got a bag of the beef and started mixing it in this morning. They LOVED it. Now let's see how they do on it.

Anyone have any experience with the Prairie?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11,445 Posts
I tried the Evo with Abbey but it was too rich for her (LOTS of protein) and no matter how much or how little I gave her, she had really loose stools.

I've heard good things about the Prairie, but haven't tried it yet! It's a bit on the expensive side, isn't it?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,939 Posts
We've been feeding this to Bella for about 7 or 8 months. She was on Canidae for many years, but we switched off of it right before they changed their formula. So far, she'd done quite well on it and really enjoys it (she seemed to be getting kind of bored with the Canidae).

We started with the Venison variety for a couple of bags and then rotated to the chicken. She's almost done with the 3rd bag of chicken, so we'll probably rotate again - maybe to lamb. (Bella starting taking a thyroid supplement a couple months ago, so we have been holding off a bit on rotating her food so we could more easily monitor her weight.)

I think we'll probably use the chicken variety as the standard and always go back to that after rotating to something else.
So something like this: venison -> chicken -> lamb -> chicken -> beef -> chicken , etc...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11,362 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
We've been feeding this to Bella for about 7 or 8 months. She was on Canidae for many years, but we switched off of it right before they changed their formula. So far, she'd done quite well on it and really enjoys it (she seemed to be getting kind of bored with the Canidae).

We started with the Venison variety for a couple of bags and then rotated to the chicken. She's almost done with the 3rd bag of chicken, so we'll probably rotate again - maybe to lamb. (Bella starting taking a thyroid supplement a couple months ago, so we have been holding off a bit on rotating her food so we could more easily monitor her weight.)

I think we'll probably use the chicken variety as the standard and always go back to that after rotating to something else.
So something like this: venison -> chicken -> lamb -> chicken -> beef -> chicken , etc...
So how often do you rotate? Do you need to mix in or are they really interchangeable? Do you find they need to eat less? The ingredient list is amazing! They are going to eat better than I am!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,939 Posts
So how often do you rotate? Do you need to mix in or are they really interchangeable? Do you find they need to eat less? The ingredient list is amazing! They are going to eat better than I am!!
So how often do you rotate?
We are targeting to rotate every 2 (30#) bags - (for 1 dog).

Do you need to mix in or are they really interchangeable?
Probably depends on how tolerant your dogs are. We do a little bit of mix in during transition, but just for a few days.

Do you find they need to eat less?
Canidae was more calorically dense than Nature's Variety, so we are actually feeding a tad more now (about a cup each for breakfast and dinner for a 67-70# medium energy 8-year old *****).
There are also caloric differences between the different varieties, so that complicates the portioning a bit. (Chicken is the least at 391 cal/cup and venison is the most at 434.)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
534 Posts
We feed this to Raven. It is the only food she does really well on. She has some food issues and this food is great for her. She loves it too.
We had to feed a little less than other foods she has eaten. The only problem is with tapioca as the only binding ingredient we have had a few bags that were very crumbly, so much to the extent that we had the throw them out. We only feed the chicken variety so far. I would recommend it!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,546 Posts
My lab eats Canidae, however, my Mini Aussie and my parent's Sheltie are on the Natures Variety (currently eating the lamb one) and they love it. The Sheltie is picky and really seems to enjoy the NV. Also, the Aussie's coat has improved on the NV, she's very glossy and shiney now (she's black). It also helped her dandruff. My Aussie has trouble keeping her weight down, however, so we'll see how this one works out for her. She was eating Innova and it was just way too caloric for her.
So far I'm happy with it. I have not decided if we'll rotate or not, for now they like the lamb.
 
1 - 7 of 7 Posts
Top