So I took your advice from the other night, and I have tried Harlee out of her crate three times at night. Twice were successful in keeping her out of her crate until 2am, so already I felt much better. She has a harder time "settling" when she is not in her crate but I am going to continue to try it because I would feel soooooooooo much better if she wasn't crated at night!

If anyone has any ideas on getting her to settle and going to sleep as easily as she does when she is in her crate, I am all ears!

Thanks again!