4 health vs diamond naturals puppy/dog food

[gbro223]

I have a 15 week old lab puppy and she has been eating some cheap food from walmart and i want to switch her to something better because she is not doing to good on the other. I have decided on 4 health or diamond naturals. They both have really good looking ingredients, and have a 4 star rating. I just cant decide which one to get. Theres not a big difference in price, which would you say is the best? Whats the difference really? Anyone tried either of these? I called the local tractor supply store and they carry both. Thanks for any advice you can give.

[BigBrownDog]

I have not tried either and never heard of 4 Health. Good luck!

[Bookwormbiker]

I feed Duke 4Health. I started when he was about 4-5 months old (after trying 3-4 other brands) and have had no problems at all. He has plenty of energy, his coat is super shiny and his stools are well-formed and he's not gassy. The vet asked me at his last visit what I fed him because he looked so great. I'd get the smaller size bag of whatever you chose in the event that your pup doesn't do well on it. Oh, and don't forget to make the change gradual. Our local Tractor Supply sells a lot of other good brands too. Purina Pro Plan, TOTW, Blue Wilderness, to mention a few.
What was the breeder feeding your pup when you got it? Did they make any recommendations?

[gbro223]

She was on pedigree

[Dani]

I am an avid feeder of Diamond. I've never heard of 4Health. But Diamond has been consistently great for my dogs over the years.

[Bookwormbiker]

4Health is manufactured by Diamond Pet Food exclusively for Tractor Supply.

[gbro223]

Thanks for the help!